Time For White Cards?

We have had two weekends in a row where the match officials in the Premier League have made massive blunders. Blunders that are costing sides much needed points in what may turn out to be a very close season.


source
Definite penalty shout.

source

Last weekend we saw harry Maguire of Manchester United impede César Azpilicueta of Chelsea only for the referee to ignore the incident. Replays clearly showed it was a foul and a penalty. I am not saying Everton would have won the match as goals do change games but it was a possible three points instead on one.
ElPdDq5XgAMk4vF.jpg
source
Schmeichel was not impeded and the goal should have been allowed. The ball never touched the Arsenal player so offside should not come into it either.

Last night Arsenal had the ball in the back of the net on more than one occasion with none of them being allowed. The one goal where the match officials said the defender was impeding the goal keeper was laughable as he was more than 1 meter away from him.

What does not make sense is the officials have their touch line assistants plus the VAR who is supposedly a qualified referee and they also have an assistant. It is taking 5 officials to screw this up and the referee who is in charge needs to take full blame.

The referee is in charge of the game and everyone else is there to make sure he makes the right decision. The touch side monitor is available if he is not sure and in my honest opinion should be checking regularly over riding his assistants.

This is not difficult and Dermot Gallagher an ex referee is having trouble trying to cover for their mistakes. Dermot is a guest on Sky Sports and is there for any questions dealing with the officiating. he doesn't want to slander anyone but it is high time people came out and called it for what it is.

There is nothing wrong with the technology and the idea behind using it as it should be straight forward. The problem lies with the people running and refereeing the game. surely it is high time after the incompetence shown that these individuals are removed and replaced. I would also suggest a few ex players involved with VAR who are there for guidance. This needs to be rectified otherwise the league is becoming a joke.

The other day I mentioned that a possible answer is to offer each team a white card where they can flag something they are not happy with. If found to be correct they get to keep the card until it is over ruled. The match official would have to go to the touch side monitor to make this call and I believe it would make things far more even with everyone having the same opportunity. The card could be used at any time and you have only one shot at it if you get it wrong.

What would make it easy for teams is they would have an official of their own or someone that understands the rules watching a monitor close by who would then highlight when to use their card. I believe this is the only system that would work right now until the standards of the officiating are raised.



0
0
0.000
9 comments
avatar

Xhaka clearly blocking the view of the keeper :D ffs, refs in premier league are just incompetent. If the refs were punished for their mistakes premier league would have to import refs because they would not have enough to do the job...

0
0
0.000
avatar

I still don't understand why VAR works so badly in England. I understand that there are mistakes everywhere and sometimes the plays are difficult to judge, but there are plays that one repetition is enough to make a decision.

0
0
0.000
avatar

I haven't seen the match and cannot find the video footage, but this is what I read on mirror.co.uk:

The Spaniard felt the decision could've gone either way but was surprised that referee Martin Atkinson didn't take a moment to review the decision.

It seems that the referee didn't watch the VAR footage. In the Dutch competition the VAR asks the referee to review the situation if they think he missed something. But it is his decision whether he does that or not.
I think it would be better when the VAR could make the final call.

Adding ex-players to the VAR crew could also improve things but then again it's often a matter of opinion. Yesterday I watched a Dutch football talkshow where they discussed a debatable penalty. The analysts (all ex-players) still couldn't agree whether it should be a penalty or not.

I really think the VAR makes football more fair. I've seen many players being sent off due to VAR footage for fouls that were missed by the umpire and linesmen. But I think it should be used for obvious misses by the umpire.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Congratulations @cryptoandcoffee! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You distributed more than 24000 upvotes. Your next target is to reach 25000 upvotes.

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Do not miss the last post from @hivebuzz:

Hivebuzz support the Papillon Foundation Charity project
0
0
0.000
avatar

Also, VAR and the referee had made recently officiating blunders that have caused Liverpool FC some crucial points. Two weeks ago when Liverpool FC played against Everyone, Jordan Henderson's goal was being disallowed. Coming to this week Sunday against Sheffield United, the away team were being awarded an undue penalty. The foul was clearly outside the 18 yard box.

0
0
0.000
avatar

There have been many cases that would have changed the game entirely. This needs to be fixed as it is unfair on the teams.

0
0
0.000
avatar

It's making feel that VAR is biased

0
0
0.000
avatar

Thank you for your engagement on this post, you have recieved ENGAGE tokens.

0
0
0.000