Herb Dean stopped that fight unnecessarily

Herb Dean is probably the best official that the UFC has ever had. There have been a bunch of really bad ones, some average ones, and then the pioneers who as far as I know just decided to move on like Big John McCarthy. Herb has been the guy that presides over the most important matches and I have seen him make very few mistakes.

I think he made a big mistake today


src

Sean O’ Malley was without doubt the better technical fighter of the two when he faced off against first-timer Kris Moutinho, who was brought up to the fight on just 11 days notice (I only just found this out myself.) As far as I knwo Moutinho wasn't even signed with UFC before this bout so he was an unusual choice for the first fight on the main card today and a guy I had never even heard of and doesn't even have much of a past as far as the internet is concerned and MMA.

Although he was definitely outclassed in every way by Sean O' Malley in the octagon, the guy can definitely take a beating and has a chin like no one I have seen in recent times and honestly, I can't believe he survived the first round, let alone the 2nd. When the 3rd round began and he actually got a few good hits in on O' Malley I was actually cheering for the guy the way that the Russian crowd starts to cheer for Rocky in Rocky IV.


src

I mean, it could have happened, Moutinho could have gotten a lucky strike in and been the upset of the year as he was a +nearly 1000 underdog on the vegas lines and there is no denying that Sean O'Malley is the better fighter of the two. There is just one thing that people aren't considering: Despite the beating that Moutinho took for nearly 15 minutes, the guy never gave up, never gassed out, and never looked like he was rattled. Sure, his face looked like a train-wreck but I've seen worse in UFC fights and if you watch the sport the way that I do, you probably have as well.


src

The fight was absolutely electric because on the few times that Moutinho made contact, there were times that O'Malley looked like he might be looking a bit shook and perhaps even facing a KO. This is all raw speculation of course because there was only 30 seconds left in the fight when Herb Dean did something I have never seen before.

We had 2 fighters that were both still fighting, both still upright, no one was looking like they were in any serious danger other than Moutinho taking significant strike after significant strike, and the fight was basically carrying on how it had been since the opening bell. Dean all of a sudden steps in and calls the fight off even though nothing had really changed since 14 and half minutes ago.


efff551e4a00d2adeb5a5bd0df044d17.jpg
src

There was no doubt that O' Malley was going to win on points by unanimous decision.... none whatsoever, but the fact that Dean didn't allow this fresh fighter to finish the fight, which at that point it was pretty damn clear that he could, was very surprising to me. I mean literally nothing had changed since the opening round: O' Malley was landing a ton of strikes but all but a few of them didn't seem to have much effect on Moutinho and his stupid lime green hair.

Myself and some friends started speculating that perhaps there might be a "Vegas" reason why this is the case and I want you to hear me out on this. There are a TON of ways that you can bet on a fight and one of them is that Moutinho makes it all the way through all 3 rounds and also that O' Malley wins by decision. Obviously, both of these would have MASSIVE payouts because on paper, there is nobody including Moutinho that would expect either of these things to happen.

I think that Herb Dean stopped the fight early to prevent bookmaking losses. I can't really think of any other reason why he would do it because those moments before the stoppage were exactly the same as the rest of the bout.

Because there is so much money riding on these fights it isn't beyond the realm of possibility that Dean was instructed beforehand to make certain that the fight didn't go all the way to the end and that appears to be exactly what happened.

At least both guys got "fight of the night" bonuses for their performances and it was well-deserved. Also, even though he is starting out his UFC career at 0-1 (which would have almost certainly been the end result anyway) I have a tremendous amount of respect for Kris Moutinho now. There are very few fighters that I have ever seen take a beating like that and refuse to give up. I can only hope that Dana White noticed this as well and gives the guy some shots in the future. I think there is a real future for the guy.

Even though he won, I think O' Malley got made look weak in this battle because none of his strikes seemed to have much impact on his opponent's resolve and Sean was backpedaling almost the entire match.

I will be looking for Kris Moutinho in the future and hope he gets the good paychecks and fights that he deserves after his performance tonight.



0
0
0.000
8 comments
avatar

I think everyone was won over by this guys toughness. Not exactly the smartest way to fight as this guy needs a defence. I know at one count he had taken 208 head shots lol and possibly was in his best interest to stop this one before he got serious damage. I think it is is own fault as he should of defended far better and then would have had a chance of wearing his opponent out. O'Malley was worried though as he kept looking at the clock as he was gassing himself out. Best fight of the night by far and can't believe this guy was given this chance just 11 days ago.

0
0
0.000
avatar

i think they did him a great disservice by cutting the fight short. He made it that far, what damage was left to be done in the remaining 30 seconds?

He could be just one of those guys that is impossible to KO like Roy Nelson who took a beating basically every fight but only got KO'd once in his career by Mark Hunt.

0
0
0.000
avatar

I think Herb Deán is a good referee who has had some bad decisions recently, this one I don't think was a bad decision, the fighters life is first and foremost the punishment he had taken was brutal, literally the guy stopped all the punches with his face.

0
0
0.000
avatar

literally the guy stopped all the punches with his face.

Yeah, haha. Dude can take a beating that is for sure. Now to work on some actual offense / defense.

0
0
0.000
avatar

I like your theory. Very probable...I did not complain too much about the stoppage because the damage accumulated was stacking up, poor Moutinho.

It also made me wonder how strong Sean is...Maybe he is more a volume striker than a sniper as he is being potrayed.

0
0
0.000
avatar

It also made me wonder how strong Sean is

Yeah, it made me think about that as well. The highlights of Sean seem like he puts the lights out on his opponents but this fight looked very different. I don't think this win did many favors for O'Malley as many people are talking about exactly what you said.

He is a crowd favorite though, and that goes a long way in the UFC.

0
0
0.000
avatar

He is a good referee

0
0
0.000
avatar

oh for sure, he is likely the best that UFC has still. It just seemed very odd to me at the time.

0
0
0.000