Tribes and engagement . Which tribe pays the most for engaging ? 4 Tribe comparison .

in LeoFinance3 months ago (edited)

Good morning to everyone , I have been running engagement project for over a month now and I am happy with how it is going so far .

Many of you might already know that engagement is important for any tribe here on Hive .

Today we shall look at 4 tribes - LEO , CTP , SPORTS and STEM to see how many users are getting rewards and how many comments are getting upvoted and how much you can earn on an average engaging with others .

Engagement = Earnings

Note: The data below is for the period - 9th March to 15th March - so the earnings will be from 16th March to 22nd March

Note 2: All the author rewards for comments are considered and posts are removed

Number of comments made vs Number of comments upvoted

Upvoted vs Not upvoted LEO.png

Upvoted vs Not Upvoted CTP(1).png

Upvted vs Not Upvoted STEM.png

Upvoted vs Not Upvoted SPORTS.png

Well in the above 4 CTP and SPORTS tends to do well because 1 in 2 comments gets upvoted in SPORTS and CTP . But if we just consider that it won't be enough , we need to focus on earnings too .

Author rewards comparison

TokensLEOCTPSTEMSPORTS
Total author rewards in 7 days790.12839.263336.943833641369.8
Per Comment Average0.1400.641.892942882862.0561828
Per User Average0.8864.036.7383664.9
What does this tell us ?

Total author rewards in 7 days - This is only for comments . So the comments made from 9th March to 15th March got author rewards of 790 LEO , 839 CTP and so on .

Per Comment Average - This tells us what is the average earnings per comment ( which has been upvoted ) , non upvoted comments aren't considered here . It is 0.14 LEO means an average upvote is 0.14 LEO on a comment.

Per User Average - This tells us how much is the average author rewards for comments per User. I might have posted 3 comments , I got upvoted only on 2 so my earnings will be for 2 comments only , so it is better to take Per User Average too .

Author rewards comparison in Hive

Well although the above gives us a picture , to better understand and compare we need to convert those rewards to Hive . I won't bore you with numbers so here are the charts -

Total author rewards when converted to Hive.png

  1. LEO is just in another league here
  2. CTP and SPORTS are almost equal
  3. STEM might seem low but it is not since the number of comments is less in STEM .

Per comment avg in Hive .png

  1. Now this is interesting , total author rewards ( 1st Bar chart ) showed LEO 10x higher than others but here it is 2x higher why ? Because the amount of comments made on LEO is just too much when compared to others so it brings down the average comment earnings a bit but still it is 2x more .

  2. In the 1st chart we saw STEM as just 24 Hive total author rewards but if you see here , it is next to LEO , that means there is a big opportunity for you to earn more Hive ( actually STEM ) if you post from STEM .

  3. STEM and SPORTS are almost equal , CTP is less when compared to other 3 .

Per user avg in Hive.png

If we come to per user earnings , CTP , STEM and SPORTS are almost equal and LEO is 3x more .


Basically if you want to earn rewards , you can hop on to any tribe and engage but the important point is you have to have interest in that tribe , otherwise you won't be able to comment a lot . If you are interested and if you are willing to engage then you can earn a lot by just commenting.

Just keep engaging and put lots of efforts , you will earn the rewards . Be consistent .


Regards,

MR.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Sort:  

I am fairly new here and a few link to those tribes would be great and much appreciated! Otherwise a fine article!

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

I am sorry about that ,

Here are the links .

Leo - https://leofinance.io

CTP - https://ctptalk.com

Stem - https://STEMGeeks.net

Sports - https://sportstalksocial.com

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

So if I'm reading this right....CTP has the highest comments voted on?

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

It is a nice practice to reward comments. I used to do that ob Steem but saw some people try to cut corners and say things like, good post or nice picture. Perhaps they assumed I used autovoter which wouldn't recognize genuine engagement from fake activity. Haha, they were wrong! And I'm very glad more replies on Leo have been genuine.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

That has decreased to a great extent over here I guess. I rarely see a "nice post" type of comment . Maybe they know they won't get upvotes for that BS .

Also manual curation is the way to go.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

I would have to say "nice comment" to you because I really mean it haha!

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Lol , well as long as you mean it ;p

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

It's kind of amazing how LEO is fairly high on all the statistics. It shows that engagement matters and your engagement is likely to be rewarded on any of these 4 tribes. It should also extend to other tribes as well.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Yeah definitely , it took me a lot of time to extract data for these 4 tribes so I didn't add more tribes but it is highly likely all tribes pay the users well for their engagement .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Very interesting. I've noticed that my comments on LEO aren't upvoted as often as posts seems to be which I'm sure is the pattern on all other platforms.

Another interesting stat would be to look at upvotes on comments from people other than the main post author although I'm not sure that the stats can differentiate.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Oh that would require a bit more effort but good idea. Next time if I decide to post about this again I will definitely try to include that stats.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

I've noticed that my comments on LEO aren't upvoted as often as posts seems to be which I'm sure is the pattern on all other platforms.

I see , you seem to be an outlier with respect to this stat then because I tried to search for a few people specifics and they get more upvotes ( not in terms of value , number of upvotes) on comments but there is another factor too - the more you comment the better your chances are to get upvotes.

Take sports and stem , I personally have seen upvotes for almost 1 in 2 comments .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

I knew that LEO will win in terms of $ or hive value.
But i was really hopping CTP to be on 2nd place as i though there is a good engagement there.
This all depends on the current price as well as CTP is fluctuating a lot.

You are correct Harpreet . All the values in Hive is represented at the latest price of each token . Even a slight increase in them will alter the results and maybe it will take CTP to 2nd place.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

CTP it is. Nice one @amr008. Interest is very important. Mine dies away very often. 👻

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Yeah I understand lol but since CTP is used on most of the posts , it has become generic in a sense so no matter what your interest is you can go over there and chat .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Yes, that's true. I see there are many generic coins we have!!!

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Yeah that's why I always stress on including the generic tags on the posts so that people earn those extra tokens .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

What are your favorite general tags? I use Palnet, Neoxian, ProofofBrain, Archon & CTP.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Same , those are the exact ones I use . I sometimes use hustler and mancave but that doesn't give anything much .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Does mancave give out any coins? Or is it just a community tag?
Never used Hustler before, will look into it.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Mancave is just a BRO tag . The BRO team curates those posts ( not sure if they do it ) .

Hustler pays HUSTLER coin but it isn't worth much right now .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Okay. Thanks for the info @amr008.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Interesting stats you've pulled up here as usual! It does show how rewarding commenting could be, plus it puts us out there for more people to see. Of course, engaging/commenting shouldn't be made a chore but it does come easier if we are interacting with posts that resonate with us personally.
-@arrliinn

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Very interesting. You have no idea about these things till you see some stats.
Thanks for doing this @amr008.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

My pleasure @erikah , I was wondering about this too yesterday like how much are people earning for just commenting so I decided to make this post .

!WINE

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta


Congratulations, @amr008 You Successfully Shared 0.100 WINE With @erikah.
You Earned 0.100 WINE As Curation Reward.
You Utilized 1/2 Successful Calls.

wine-greeting
Total Purchase : 24809.918 WINE & Last Price : 0.290 HIVE
HURRY UP & GET YOUR SPOT IN WINE INITIAL TOKEN OFFERING -ITO-


WINE Current Market Price : 0.500 HIVE

That's very interesting! What I like is that it seems comments are getting upvoted quite regularly!

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

If you would have asked me to guess before even reading this post I totally would have guessed Leo. It is just crazy over here. People are so active and the rewards flow so freely.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Wow the number of comments being upvoted is fantastic! except for STEM, but wow that's impressive. Thanks for sharing this data, and personally I upvote nearly every comment that I receive on my content to show my appreciation for those that take the time to stop by and engage.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

I reason for less upvotes on STEM is because of tag farming to be honest , a lot of overlapping between LEO and STEM takes place and only STEM related content gets upvoted on STEMGeeks .

I upvote nearly every comment that I receive on my content to show my appreciation for those that take the time to stop by and engage.

I have observed :) We need more like you .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Thank You
I have to be more active on ctp also

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Hehe yes , just like we diversify investments I think diversification in engagement too will pay off .

!WINE

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta


Congratulations, @amr008 You Successfully Shared 0.200 WINE With @natalia-irish.
You Earned 0.200 WINE As Curation Reward.
You Utilized 2/2 Successful Calls.

wine-greeting
Total Purchase : 24809.918 WINE & Last Price : 0.290 HIVE
HURRY UP & GET YOUR SPOT IN WINE INITIAL TOKEN OFFERING -ITO-


WINE Current Market Price : 0.500 HIVE

I've said it before, engagement is where the compounding effect of earning tokens really shines. Yes, you can make a lot more by posting something. But, if you consistently curate on a daily basis, you will see tokens flow into your wallet every single day. Those get staked and then added to the next day, and the next, and the next. Pretty soon your votes are worth more and you're getting even more from your comments. It just takes a little effort and consistency. Nice post, again. :-)

Very well put , I guess you should take over the content part to my post , I would be happy to just get the data lol .

But on a serious note , you are right , I wish we can see engagement getting more rewarded than the posts itself ( overall author rewards ) that will make people realize the importance of engagement and it is good for platform .

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Intresting post and analysis.
Leo is leading and standing at first position one reason is good price of leo also...
Thanks for sharing
Keep doing good work.

Hey thanks guurry123 sir. Yes right now in terms of earnings Leo is ahead but if you take upvote to non-upvote ratio then CTP is leading.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

Thats another great example of the analytics about the tribes. I really like to read your reports