Should they have stopped the Crute fight at UFC 261?

in Sports Talk Social3 months ago

UFC 261 was one of the most electrifying pay-per-view events I have ever seen and I have been watching UFC for many years. On the main card there wasn't a single boring fight and I complain when fights go the distance in a boring fashion. Well we certainly didn't have that because only 2 of the fights made it out of the first round. It might have been one of the fastest PPV main cards of all time.


UFC-261-online-free.jpg
src
there are good cards, great cards, stacked cards, and then there are cards like this

One of the fights that surprised me the most was the Smith vs Crute fight in that I have never seen a medical stoppage ever occur in a fight because of a "dead leg." I can understand where they were coming from but the funny thing about this particular instance was the fact that Crute, who was the one deemed unfit to continue, didn't really seem to have an advantage at any point in time except for after the injury.


1232507630.0.jpg
src

Late in the 1st round, Anthony Smith hit Jim Crute with what appeared to be just your run of the mill leg kick, catching him just above the knee. However, after Crute absorbed the hit he collapsed and appeared to not have use of that leg anymore. However, shortly thereafter, he was actually the aggressor and seemed to have control of the rest of the round achieving top position on the ground.


jimmy-crute-ufc-261-1.jpg
src

Normally when something like this happens, your opponent who is still standing will swarm and quickly achieve a KO or TKO victory but precisely the opposite happened. Crute seemed to be very comfortable on the ground and for the first time in the match had the clear upper hand.

It wasn't until the round ended and Crute had difficulty walking that some real attention was drawn to his injury. The crowd gasped in horror as he kept rolling his ankle, apparently unable to feel his leg at all.

He protested with the ring doctor telling him that he could continue, he insisted that he could and in my mind he kind of proved that he could continue by basically dominating the end of round 1. However, it was pretty evident that he was unable to put any weight on his left leg.

This was the first time I have ever seen a doctor stoppage for a "leg malfunction."

I don't know if the doctor made the correct decision or not but I like to believe they have some sort of medical criteria for deciding the fighters fate that I am just too uneducated to understand. There is no denying that having use of your legs is a huge factor in MMA and I think that this situation would have sorted itself out early into the 2nd round anyway if they had simply allowed the fight to run its course.

When the doctor called the fight, Crute punched the octagon in what might have been his strongest jab of the entire fight. He obviously wanted to continue and I would have preferred had they let him do so. The sensation in his leg came back just a few minutes later, although he was still clearly wobbled. He gave about as civil an interview as can be expected to Joe Rogan after the fight was decided.


218704.jpg
src

I don't really understand the justification for medical stoppage and I would have liked to see a bit more. If the knee was that much of an issue Anthony Smith would have been able to finish it pretty quickly, but you never know. This injury might have been a temporary thing just like when you see guys get rocked, look like they are done and then come back to win.

There is no precedent for this that I am aware of, but I don't think the doc made the right call in this situation. I don't think that Jimmy was in danger of additional or permanent damage due to this injury the way that a massive cut or eye poke would do.

What do you think? Should they have let this one go longer or did the doc make the correct call?

Sort:  

I really think it was because of the audience pressure. The governor of the state is here, celebrities, VIPs, and you cannot stall the fight for too long.
I would have liked a 5 minutes recovery time, the same way they get for kicking nuts and eyes pokes. I know there is technically "nothing illegal" in those calf kicks, but I can tell you that they are THAT IMPORTANT, and game changers, for not bending rules around them.
It will happen again, trust me. Don't you remember O'Malley's fight against Andre Soukhamthath ?
It happened right in the middle of a round, and if the ref decided to stand up the fighters instead of having Andre keeping the fight to the ground if I remember correctly (that was quite suspect at the time by the way), well Sean would have clearly not been able to stand on his foot. He ended up winning the fight by unanimous decision, very weird.

Jimmy will be fine, I can tell you he will bounce back and be better than ever. He learnt as well something in this fight, don't march forward like a bull offering your leading leg to be chopped.

I know there is technically "nothing illegal" in those calf kicks, but I can tell you that they are THAT IMPORTANT,

I have seen leg kicks becoming more and more of a factor in recent PPV's. Even Conor admits that this was the main reason why he was unable to perform. Sometimes me and my friends will speak about how if i kicked them in the leg like that they would go down, but so would i if I didn't have a shoe on... maybe even if I did. :)

I hope Jimmy does get another chance at a big card. He deserves more attention and the way he handled the stoppage with class says a lot about the dude.

Sometimes me and my friends will speak about how if i kicked them in the leg like that they would go down, but so would i if I didn't have a shoe on... maybe even if I did. :)

Lol some good ol' friendly banter with calves kicks...

I hope Jimmy does get another chance at a big card. He deserves more attention and the way he handled the stoppage with class says a lot about the dude.

Yeah, he showed lot's of passion too, the way he reacted to the stoppage. It was kind heartbraking in some ways...

Congratulations @sports.guy55! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You made more than 500 comments.
Your next target is to reach 600 comments.

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Support the HiveBuzz project. Vote for our proposal!

I missed all actions from this round of ufc. But I am glad that my Usman did Nigeria proud by wining. It was a sight worth seeing

Yes, he certainly showed us that he is no paper tiger and that he is definitely to be feared. Now can he do the same to Colby Covington?

From my understanding the doc stoppages are meant to prevent terrible damage to a fighter. This one is a tough call because nothing was broken, he wasn't cut, he was trying his best to hide his limp but in the end I think the doc's decision might have been affected by the way in which the crowd was reacting and what happened between rounds.

I don't think they should have stopped it either as it likely would have stopped itself in the first minute of round 2 anyway.

In the press conference, Dana said he thought it was a serious injury. But I can't find anything online about Crute having a serious injury. His instagram just says that he's gutted by the stoppage.

This doctor explains what might have happened, and why a fight doctor would have stopped the fight.

This was definitely a bad event for legs, but a great event for fans! Even though I lost all of my Weili bets :(

Ok, this is a nice breakdown and certainly helped me to understand the ring doctor's logic. Of course the ring doctor was under a lot more pressure to assess the situation quickly and I wonder what was going through his mind at the time... he obviously didn't have the time needed to go through this level of analysis and was going on visuals alone.

That being said I haven't read anything about what was actually wrong with Crute. I'll probably look into that now

Even though I lost all of my Weili bets

I'm quite certain a lot of other people did as well. I didn't have time to place any but I would be willing to bet that a Rose KO 1st round would have been a VERY BIG payout as no one saw that coming.