I think I might would take the used one. I say this as if they fix the leak, what if there was more than one? And, how trustworthy is the repair person? Will they just say they fixed it and take your money? Is there a guarantee with their work? It's disheartening to replace spoiled food when your fridge goes bad. I've had that happen several times in the past, either due to faulty equipment, or power outages that lasted longer than the fridge could. If the used ones are better quality, then seriously consider it. If they offer a warranty with it, that's even better. That's my opinion for what it's worth, but pray about it as well. You did well with your 5026 @actifit steps for the day. Take care, my brother. God will provide what you need.